Saturday, August 7, 2010

What's in a Role Play?

Thirst... unquenchable and ever-lasting, and I am not talking for knowledge. WATER! I needed it, all the time, at every minute of the day, it seemed. These are my memories of teaching for the past few years. Why? As a teacher, I talk constantly and yet I am not the one who needs to learn English, or so I'd like to think. So, what better way for me to save on my bottled water budget than role plays in my classroom.

When I first thought about doing drama with Romeo and Juliet last year, I was excited about the thought of the actual story in the play - romance, drama, violence - all of the things teenagers love. We started with various stories about love and used the QTEL method of writing part of the story in dialogue form and acting it out to the class. It went well but since my students were still new to English and everyone read different stories, it was hard to grasp the concept of some of their dialogues. Then, we moved on to Romeo and Juliet and I attempted to have students read Act 1, Scene 1...big, fat flop! Really. Absolutely terrible. I gave students the No Fear Shakespeare version and assumed that with heterogeneous reading groups (strong readers with weaker readers combined), they would be able to help each other get through the scene. Not so. I was greeted around the room with pained expression. One of my most advanced students, Wilssy Martinez, finally looked at me and said, "This is too much." Ugh.

I then attempted reading as a class and watching the movie. Yet, even as we read together, I found myself doing more of the talking than anyone else in the room. More water, please.

Students ended the unit with re-writing the ending of Romeo and Juliet the way they would have liked to have seen it. The dramas were solid but still relatively simple - a lot of Romeo and Juliets running off into the sunset together and escaping the evil clutches of their families. Fairly predictable, as you might have guessed. They were better than our dialogues from the love stories students had presented the month before, but I felt like the dramas still lacked something - some sort of reflection, depth, critical thinking. I also didn't do any sort of writing at the end of the unit, which bothered me even more. At the end, was I sure they got the ideas of theme, characterization and symbolism? No sir.

When I did Othello, we started doing more role plays as per my colleague Nancy's suggestion and the ideas from a book called Shakespeare Set Free. We didn't give names to characters but just gave students situations at the beginning and throughout the play - like pretend you are trying to convince your friend that his girlfriend is unfaithful - and our students ran with it. Literally. It was hysterical to watch them attempt to convince each other that their "girl," or sometimes "guy," was cheating. They were then able to relate the situation they had acted out in class with the situation they began to read about between Iago and Othello. They came up with interesting ideas, made connections to their own lives and began to see character motivations. Magic! This led to better final essays, which I had not done the year before. Better yet, although I had recently purchased a reusable water bottle in an attempt to be greener, I wasn't as thirsty. My students were doing the talking.

As I begin thinking about The Crucible, I am looking to set up the situation at the beginning of the play and throughout the acts with role plays. Here are some ideas so far - In the beginning when Rev. Parris sees that his daughter is sick and Abigail tries to wake her, I am thinking of having students act out this possible situation: you were with friend the night before even though you did not have permission. Your friend is now sick in bed and will not speak. Your friend is worried that his/her parents are angry. You know your friend is okay. What happens?


This is just a thought for Act 1 and I will be moving through to Acts 2 and 3 as time allows. Regardless, with these types of role plays I aim to have students engaging with the text on a personal level, relating to characters and developing possible arguments for their motivations (i.e. character analysis theses for final essays). In other words, they can lead the class discussions and form their own ideas, which of course the role plays facilitate. And although I have my handy reusable water bottle, I hope this year can be a little greener...and I a little less thirsty.

1 comment:

  1. What a unique approach to teaching! Shakespeare is difficult for even native speakers to grasp, it's amazing that you discovered a way to make it accesible to non-native speakers. Can't wait to hear more about this process! Also, congrats on going green :-)

    ReplyDelete