I was doing some of my summer planning before going away and had a grand idea for an opening role play situation for The Crucible -
You and a friend were out without permission and your friend's parents saw you both out. Your friend denies it and pretends to be sick. Meanwhile, your friend's parents confront you about your night out and lies that you two told. What happens?
I had written some other, similar ideas about this opening act a few weeks ago and have been trying to come up with simple ways to relate the conflict of Reverend Parris, Betty and Abigail in Act 1 of The Crucible in the classroom. The real-life problem that I described above is not an exact recreation, but it might just work to lay the foundations for what occurs in the opening scene of Miller's drama. One of the keys, I found, with Othello, was to relate a modern-day situations to the work of literature.
It enabled students to use the role-play that they saw their classmates perform to their reading. In addition, students could then apply their colleagues' actions to the written work, and say things like "Well, Yoaris, who was like Othello, gets jealous and starts yelling at Mohamed, who was like Iago." Hopefully I am explaining this properly, but basically the class scene allows students to visualize what they are reading and creates an actual, image of the scene in their head to which they can refer when reading or discussing the piece of literature (which I think I have said many times before). This is essential for ELLs who are still struggling with reading comprehension, as are many of my students. It gives them a "head start" to what they are reading, instead of my front-loading with tons of written material, talking, explaining... and more talking (please refer to my bottled water commentary below). More importantly, my planning got me thinking about student experience, especially with our school's population and how these spontaneous dramas further assist understanding the relationship between art and life
As you may have guessed, my students come from a variety of backgrounds. I have students who do not remember meeting their parents before coming to America and others who only have few childhood memories of their mothers and fathers in their home country. Some have fled civil warfare, risking their lives to cross borders and eventually sought a new life in the United States. Some have children of their own and have come here to find opportunities for themselves, along with their sons or daughters. Many have jobs to buy sneakers while some work to the pay rent for their families or send money to those they left behind. Even a few, for some reason or another, now live by themselves, essentially as full-fledged adults (our so we think). While of my students are thinking of going to college and becoming what they would like to call "a professional," many more, at seventeen, eighteen and nineteen years old, think about getting married and having a family of their own - sooner rather than later. Needless to say, it's a mix.
You may be asking, why does this matter? And furthermore, what does this have to do with drama in the classroom, let alone The Crucible? Well, everything about my students' experiences matters. They bring a richness of experience and sense of self to my classroom that I never had at their age. They have dealt with situations that even at twenty-nine, I have never negotiated (No kids over here, only a cat who continuously scratches my once pristine leather chairs). Of course, I have certainly had my fair share of life experiences, travel, family issues (don't we all!) and hard times, but in all honesty, sometimes I feel like my life is far less complicated than my young pupils'. If I cannot empower them to use their lives in their learning, then we have very little to go on with such a diverse community. Action in the classroom gives students a voice and a place to share themselves. People from the Dominican Republic start realizing that their Nepali counterparts are not that different after all. Students from Guinea start realizing that their brothers from Yemen were also threatened in the street while walking to the store (that came from a brief look at Richard Wright's Black Boy).
And so it goes- We were all, at one point, "kids." We have all lied to our parents (or caretakers), done things we weren't supposed to do (go ahead, ask my mom), gone to forbidden places or tried things that weren't in our best interest (really, go for it, ask!). It's almost a rite of passage for children and young adults. It's a part of growing up and a different form of learning that occurs in life, not school. Even further, temptation and curiosity are a natural part of human behavior (especially for kids, as we have all found, I think), which may be part of what Arthur Miller attempts to examine in his play (along with mass hysteria, which is an obvious theme). Those little Puritan gals, who were prancing around in the woods in the 17th Century, were kids themselves, experimenting with what some have explained as "love potions and spells." They were curious of the unknown, of the forbidden and those things that were outside of their every day realm and religion.
Whether from Bangladesh, Colombia, Nepal or Guinea, I think we can all relate to that time "when I wasn't supposed to, but I did it anyway." Relating to personal experience not only creates a unity amongst learners but also makes for animated stories, laughter and the pages of a classic written over fifty years ago come alive. I'm sure I'll have a lot to write once we get started.
Thursday, August 19, 2010
Friday, August 13, 2010
Recent article
I just wanted to share a recent article I found on new refugee students coming to NY for the first time and entering school. The older students coming in are the exact population my school, ELLIS Preparatory Academy, targets! This is exciting and I hope that some of them will be joining us this year. I will write a pedagogy post later... but enjoy for now!
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100812/ap_on_re_us/us_refugee_summer_school
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100812/ap_on_re_us/us_refugee_summer_school
Tuesday, August 10, 2010
What else?
What else about role playing in the classroom? Why else is it helpful, especially for ELLs?
Well, a good friend of mine asked me to relate my teaching to my personal experiences. I began to think of my traveling experiences and how they helped me to learn languages. I realized that I was put into situations where I was forced to speak, and think about what I was saying while I was doing it (a real life role-play). Take, for example, my first night in Brasil. I had taken a quick Portuguese course and considered myself fairly fluent in Spanish at that point, so I was confident about my language skills. Hmmmm... I floundered. I spent my first night with my new family, Deborah and Mauricio, eating my "janta" (dinner) of saltines and watermelon juice while flopping my arms to describe my viagem de aviao (airplane ride) just to get my point across. They nodded politely and helped me with pronunciation. I, of course, couldn't wait to get to bed. (**As an aside, my good friend Simrin might blame my "crackers for dinner" phenomenon of 2007-2008 on my summer in Brasil, but I will explain my food loves in another post**).
Back to my point... after two months in Brasil and many a spontaneous conversing situation behind me, I remember washing out my clothes in the kitchen and chatting with Deborah in what I would like to call "proficient" Portuguese (fluent is pushing it for that amount of time). She turned to me and said, "you learned!" And I replied, "I did learn!" Things just slowly clicked and I was finally feeling a sense of confidence in my new language.
When I look at my students, I want to inspire that same sense of confidence in them. To be totally honest, while we laugh and giggle at their performances in the audience, when my students get up to act out a situation, they are totally confident and excited to perform for the class. My thoughts are, with giving a situation to act out, there is no right or wrong answer... just acting. They can feel their way through a situation with each other and simply speak, rather than worrying about whether or not I will approve of what they say. This, in turn, opens their minds to more writing and thoughts after we look at the role play and relate it to the actual work of literature (I am currently thinking about Othello). Sometimes I think the more spontaneous the acting can be, the better. We shall see this year, I may have to do more experimenting...
Well, a good friend of mine asked me to relate my teaching to my personal experiences. I began to think of my traveling experiences and how they helped me to learn languages. I realized that I was put into situations where I was forced to speak, and think about what I was saying while I was doing it (a real life role-play). Take, for example, my first night in Brasil. I had taken a quick Portuguese course and considered myself fairly fluent in Spanish at that point, so I was confident about my language skills. Hmmmm... I floundered. I spent my first night with my new family, Deborah and Mauricio, eating my "janta" (dinner) of saltines and watermelon juice while flopping my arms to describe my viagem de aviao (airplane ride) just to get my point across. They nodded politely and helped me with pronunciation. I, of course, couldn't wait to get to bed. (**As an aside, my good friend Simrin might blame my "crackers for dinner" phenomenon of 2007-2008 on my summer in Brasil, but I will explain my food loves in another post**).
Back to my point... after two months in Brasil and many a spontaneous conversing situation behind me, I remember washing out my clothes in the kitchen and chatting with Deborah in what I would like to call "proficient" Portuguese (fluent is pushing it for that amount of time). She turned to me and said, "you learned!" And I replied, "I did learn!" Things just slowly clicked and I was finally feeling a sense of confidence in my new language.
When I look at my students, I want to inspire that same sense of confidence in them. To be totally honest, while we laugh and giggle at their performances in the audience, when my students get up to act out a situation, they are totally confident and excited to perform for the class. My thoughts are, with giving a situation to act out, there is no right or wrong answer... just acting. They can feel their way through a situation with each other and simply speak, rather than worrying about whether or not I will approve of what they say. This, in turn, opens their minds to more writing and thoughts after we look at the role play and relate it to the actual work of literature (I am currently thinking about Othello). Sometimes I think the more spontaneous the acting can be, the better. We shall see this year, I may have to do more experimenting...
Saturday, August 7, 2010
What's in a Role Play?
Thirst... unquenchable and ever-lasting, and I am not talking for knowledge. WATER! I needed it, all the time, at every minute of the day, it seemed. These are my memories of teaching for the past few years. Why? As a teacher, I talk constantly and yet I am not the one who needs to learn English, or so I'd like to think. So, what better way for me to save on my bottled water budget than role plays in my classroom.
When I first thought about doing drama with Romeo and Juliet last year, I was excited about the thought of the actual story in the play - romance, drama, violence - all of the things teenagers love. We started with various stories about love and used the QTEL method of writing part of the story in dialogue form and acting it out to the class. It went well but since my students were still new to English and everyone read different stories, it was hard to grasp the concept of some of their dialogues. Then, we moved on to Romeo and Juliet and I attempted to have students read Act 1, Scene 1...big, fat flop! Really. Absolutely terrible. I gave students the No Fear Shakespeare version and assumed that with heterogeneous reading groups (strong readers with weaker readers combined), they would be able to help each other get through the scene. Not so. I was greeted around the room with pained expression. One of my most advanced students, Wilssy Martinez, finally looked at me and said, "This is too much." Ugh.
I then attempted reading as a class and watching the movie. Yet, even as we read together, I found myself doing more of the talking than anyone else in the room. More water, please.
Students ended the unit with re-writing the ending of Romeo and Juliet the way they would have liked to have seen it. The dramas were solid but still relatively simple - a lot of Romeo and Juliets running off into the sunset together and escaping the evil clutches of their families. Fairly predictable, as you might have guessed. They were better than our dialogues from the love stories students had presented the month before, but I felt like the dramas still lacked something - some sort of reflection, depth, critical thinking. I also didn't do any sort of writing at the end of the unit, which bothered me even more. At the end, was I sure they got the ideas of theme, characterization and symbolism? No sir.
When I did Othello, we started doing more role plays as per my colleague Nancy's suggestion and the ideas from a book called Shakespeare Set Free. We didn't give names to characters but just gave students situations at the beginning and throughout the play - like pretend you are trying to convince your friend that his girlfriend is unfaithful - and our students ran with it. Literally. It was hysterical to watch them attempt to convince each other that their "girl," or sometimes "guy," was cheating. They were then able to relate the situation they had acted out in class with the situation they began to read about between Iago and Othello. They came up with interesting ideas, made connections to their own lives and began to see character motivations. Magic! This led to better final essays, which I had not done the year before. Better yet, although I had recently purchased a reusable water bottle in an attempt to be greener, I wasn't as thirsty. My students were doing the talking.
As I begin thinking about The Crucible, I am looking to set up the situation at the beginning of the play and throughout the acts with role plays. Here are some ideas so far - In the beginning when Rev. Parris sees that his daughter is sick and Abigail tries to wake her, I am thinking of having students act out this possible situation: you were with friend the night before even though you did not have permission. Your friend is now sick in bed and will not speak. Your friend is worried that his/her parents are angry. You know your friend is okay. What happens?
This is just a thought for Act 1 and I will be moving through to Acts 2 and 3 as time allows. Regardless, with these types of role plays I aim to have students engaging with the text on a personal level, relating to characters and developing possible arguments for their motivations (i.e. character analysis theses for final essays). In other words, they can lead the class discussions and form their own ideas, which of course the role plays facilitate. And although I have my handy reusable water bottle, I hope this year can be a little greener...and I a little less thirsty.
When I first thought about doing drama with Romeo and Juliet last year, I was excited about the thought of the actual story in the play - romance, drama, violence - all of the things teenagers love. We started with various stories about love and used the QTEL method of writing part of the story in dialogue form and acting it out to the class. It went well but since my students were still new to English and everyone read different stories, it was hard to grasp the concept of some of their dialogues. Then, we moved on to Romeo and Juliet and I attempted to have students read Act 1, Scene 1...big, fat flop! Really. Absolutely terrible. I gave students the No Fear Shakespeare version and assumed that with heterogeneous reading groups (strong readers with weaker readers combined), they would be able to help each other get through the scene. Not so. I was greeted around the room with pained expression. One of my most advanced students, Wilssy Martinez, finally looked at me and said, "This is too much." Ugh.
I then attempted reading as a class and watching the movie. Yet, even as we read together, I found myself doing more of the talking than anyone else in the room. More water, please.
Students ended the unit with re-writing the ending of Romeo and Juliet the way they would have liked to have seen it. The dramas were solid but still relatively simple - a lot of Romeo and Juliets running off into the sunset together and escaping the evil clutches of their families. Fairly predictable, as you might have guessed. They were better than our dialogues from the love stories students had presented the month before, but I felt like the dramas still lacked something - some sort of reflection, depth, critical thinking. I also didn't do any sort of writing at the end of the unit, which bothered me even more. At the end, was I sure they got the ideas of theme, characterization and symbolism? No sir.
When I did Othello, we started doing more role plays as per my colleague Nancy's suggestion and the ideas from a book called Shakespeare Set Free. We didn't give names to characters but just gave students situations at the beginning and throughout the play - like pretend you are trying to convince your friend that his girlfriend is unfaithful - and our students ran with it. Literally. It was hysterical to watch them attempt to convince each other that their "girl," or sometimes "guy," was cheating. They were then able to relate the situation they had acted out in class with the situation they began to read about between Iago and Othello. They came up with interesting ideas, made connections to their own lives and began to see character motivations. Magic! This led to better final essays, which I had not done the year before. Better yet, although I had recently purchased a reusable water bottle in an attempt to be greener, I wasn't as thirsty. My students were doing the talking.
As I begin thinking about The Crucible, I am looking to set up the situation at the beginning of the play and throughout the acts with role plays. Here are some ideas so far - In the beginning when Rev. Parris sees that his daughter is sick and Abigail tries to wake her, I am thinking of having students act out this possible situation: you were with friend the night before even though you did not have permission. Your friend is now sick in bed and will not speak. Your friend is worried that his/her parents are angry. You know your friend is okay. What happens?
This is just a thought for Act 1 and I will be moving through to Acts 2 and 3 as time allows. Regardless, with these types of role plays I aim to have students engaging with the text on a personal level, relating to characters and developing possible arguments for their motivations (i.e. character analysis theses for final essays). In other words, they can lead the class discussions and form their own ideas, which of course the role plays facilitate. And although I have my handy reusable water bottle, I hope this year can be a little greener...and I a little less thirsty.
Friday, August 6, 2010
The Crucible - teaching American history.
One of the most troublesome facts about my students, for me, is their lack of knowledge about American History. As young adults, they have come to this country with ideals and dreams of what "America" is based on TV, rumors and their family's experiences. Yet, as an American myself, I know how limiting this information is. As I have always said, our students, although immigrants and although new to the country, are entitled to the same education as myself. Therefore, I feel as though it is my responsibility to share my knowledge with them.
During college and graduate school, one of my greatest passions was historical fiction and history-based literature. I guess you might even translate this to a love of history, which is also true. I have always felt that art mimics life, and vice-versa, which may account for my interests in how writers reflect on historical lessons in their works. After attempting many thematic lessons over the past year, including two on Shakespeare- Romeo and Juliet and Othello, I am ready to try my hand at a year of American Literature. Through time periods, my students will hopefully receive at least some broad strokes on our American history.
First up... The Crucible. I sincerely doubt that many of my students have the slightest clue as to whom settled this country, let alone any knowledge on Puritans and their theology. Yet, as someone who was born and raised in New England, I cannot deny that somewhere that Puritan work ethic has infused my own (although I would like to say I don't hold the same ideas as Jonathan Edward's "Angry God"). Growing up, someone has said to me more than once "Idle hands are the devil's playground," and I am pretty sure it wasn't one of my Italian relatives. So, that said, I thought it would be nice to show students where these "American Dreams" started. Why did people start coming to American and who were they? Interestingly enough, they might find a few things in common with those immigrants of the 17th Century. And here we go... beginning to see that history does, in fact, repeat itself.
Better yet, this unit will be a great time for me to experiment more with drama and role play as a way to encourage higher order thinking and analytical writing. I'll keep you posted during my summer planning....
During college and graduate school, one of my greatest passions was historical fiction and history-based literature. I guess you might even translate this to a love of history, which is also true. I have always felt that art mimics life, and vice-versa, which may account for my interests in how writers reflect on historical lessons in their works. After attempting many thematic lessons over the past year, including two on Shakespeare- Romeo and Juliet and Othello, I am ready to try my hand at a year of American Literature. Through time periods, my students will hopefully receive at least some broad strokes on our American history.
First up... The Crucible. I sincerely doubt that many of my students have the slightest clue as to whom settled this country, let alone any knowledge on Puritans and their theology. Yet, as someone who was born and raised in New England, I cannot deny that somewhere that Puritan work ethic has infused my own (although I would like to say I don't hold the same ideas as Jonathan Edward's "Angry God"). Growing up, someone has said to me more than once "Idle hands are the devil's playground," and I am pretty sure it wasn't one of my Italian relatives. So, that said, I thought it would be nice to show students where these "American Dreams" started. Why did people start coming to American and who were they? Interestingly enough, they might find a few things in common with those immigrants of the 17th Century. And here we go... beginning to see that history does, in fact, repeat itself.
Better yet, this unit will be a great time for me to experiment more with drama and role play as a way to encourage higher order thinking and analytical writing. I'll keep you posted during my summer planning....
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)