We have had a great couple of weeks with Othello - students have begun to develop ideas about characters, the theme of jealousy and motives for the characters' actions. While we have not focused on any one character individually, it is hard NOT to focus on Iago. He plays such an important part in the story. I focused, in Act 1, Scene 1, on why Iago is the first person to express his opinions if the play is entitled Othello. Students are still grappling with that thought, but many of them have decided that Iago is actually the most intelligent person in the play because he is the one who controls all of the characters' actions.
Here are some more things that students have been saying about Iago to share with all of you:
Musa Njie
I think Iago tries to convince Cassio to separate him from Othello so the three of them can be the same.
Tijan Cham
I think Iago hates Othello because Othello is black and he is a general in the army. I think Iago wants to be general in the army.
Karina Genao
Iago está manipulando a todos y nadie se da cuenta de que Iago lo está engañando a todos, porque el quiere tener el control absoluto de todo.
Gregory Matos
My opinion is that now Iago is the only one who doesn’t have trouble. Everybody trusts him and then he can control or manipulate the people, like Othello, Roderigo and Cassio.
Angela Tejada
Why do the people only believe Iago? I think Iago is at the beginning of the play because he is all of the problems in the play.
I think that Iago manipulates the people when he says things that other people want to hear.
We have, of course, only reached about Act 3, Scene 1, but there is still so much more to go. I think it is best, with ELLs, to first get down the plot and then return to characterization, foreshadowing, symbolism, etc. This is too hard to teach at the same time of trying to maintain a sense of coherency in the plot. Students tend to get bogged down with language, but if you can have them first understand the story, they will latch onto new ideas later in the unit. This is just my opinion, but I think most agree that with ELLs (and maybe even Native Language students studying Shakespeare) you do need to establish the plot first and dig deeper with details afterwards.
I have been paying close attention to students' thoughts and opinions in their response logs. The way that we have set this up is by having students write down important ideas in one column and then their response in another column. This way, students can keep a daily log of what we read and their response. As I have pointed out to many students, these responses and opinions may later turn into their thesis statements for essays.
In addition, in order to incorporate groupwork, we have students maintain group binders and at the end of major scenes or acts, we have students choose jobs - illustrator, questioner, summarizer and paragraph writer (I will write more about this later). Students complete their jobs and I later intend to call on one group to present some of their work and a final thought on the scene. This gives group responsibility and allows students to develop thoughts within the group, rather than just in front of the class. It also gives our students space to process the story and their opinions, because as ELLs this can be quite intimidating and sometimes impossible to do if called "on-the-spot."
Overall, things are going well. I hope to continue the progress after a long Spring Break!
Saturday, March 27, 2010
Saturday, March 13, 2010
Teaching Othello
One of the reasons why I started this blog was to track our progress with Othello over the next coming months. My coworker, Nancy Heacock, came up with the idea of publishing our work after we make through the next few months rolling up our sleeves with Shakespeare's Othello with students whose language skills vary from rudimentary English reading and writing skills to near fluency... all in the same classroom! Regardless, we started the adventure last week with the beginnings of developing ideas in our classes around jealousy, envy, trust and love. From one of our French speaking students, I heard "Jealousy is proof of love." I'm still working on the French spelling, but I think it's something like Jalousie et prove d'amour (I swear I will learn French some day).
Regardless, this was just one of the many ideas that left me speechless, but also made me think about the concept of love and culture. Jealousy, from my student's standpoint, is necessary for love, because it demonstrates the idea of love and wanting to be with the other person. I, meanwhile, have always based my opinion of love on the idea of trust - both with yourself and others. Yet, for this particular student and many others, jealousy is part of love, and without it, it cannot exist. I began to wonder even more about relationships across cultures ... how do my ideas clash with my students? How do the ways that we conduct ourselves here compare to them and their cultures? What effects do these cultural-exchanges and changes have on our students... and really anyone coming here from around the world?
I hope to entertain you with our adventures in Othello this spring... and hopefully some of my colleagues will join in the fun... possibly even a few students!!
Regardless, this was just one of the many ideas that left me speechless, but also made me think about the concept of love and culture. Jealousy, from my student's standpoint, is necessary for love, because it demonstrates the idea of love and wanting to be with the other person. I, meanwhile, have always based my opinion of love on the idea of trust - both with yourself and others. Yet, for this particular student and many others, jealousy is part of love, and without it, it cannot exist. I began to wonder even more about relationships across cultures ... how do my ideas clash with my students? How do the ways that we conduct ourselves here compare to them and their cultures? What effects do these cultural-exchanges and changes have on our students... and really anyone coming here from around the world?
I hope to entertain you with our adventures in Othello this spring... and hopefully some of my colleagues will join in the fun... possibly even a few students!!
ELLIS Preparatory Academy
To learn a little more about our school, click here:
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/25/education/25ellis.html
We are finishing up our second year at ELLIS Preparatory Academy, where we serve students who have recently arrived to the United States from practically all over the world. Our school focuses on college and job preparation, in addition language-focused instruction to develop English speaking, reading and writing skills.
The article listed above is just a small glimpse of the work our students do at ELLIS, where they not only learn to read and write English, but are growing into upstanding citizens and residents of our country. While many people might ask, why work with this population? My answer is, I can't imagine, at this point in my life, wanting to work with anyone else. These students will make you laugh, cry and possibly leave your mouth hanging wide-open in amazement. Their bravery is outstanding, their audacity is shocking and their openness to learning a new language and culture is inspiring.
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/25/education/25ellis.html
We are finishing up our second year at ELLIS Preparatory Academy, where we serve students who have recently arrived to the United States from practically all over the world. Our school focuses on college and job preparation, in addition language-focused instruction to develop English speaking, reading and writing skills.
The article listed above is just a small glimpse of the work our students do at ELLIS, where they not only learn to read and write English, but are growing into upstanding citizens and residents of our country. While many people might ask, why work with this population? My answer is, I can't imagine, at this point in my life, wanting to work with anyone else. These students will make you laugh, cry and possibly leave your mouth hanging wide-open in amazement. Their bravery is outstanding, their audacity is shocking and their openness to learning a new language and culture is inspiring.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)