One of the things we decided to do was to create dramas before writing. As said in my previous post, the "excerpted scenes" preceded any actual essay writing. Yet, the movement and action of the dramas allowed our students to think more clearly about different themes, symbols and motifs throughout the play. When it came time to write the actual essay, students discussed different themes and then grouped themselves by interest. They thought of specific examples of the themes and helped each other gather evidence as they designed their thesis statements.
Next year, I hope to have a different system where students think of themes or characters and then gather quotes throughout the reading of the play (The Crucible)... I found this to be our greatest challenge when writing essays with ELLs. Sometimes, they don't know where to begin!
Here is a sample of one of my student's essays. Gabriela Flamenco, from El Salvador, is one of my strongest writers, but as you can see, she is beginning to develop a strong argument based on her observations of Desdemona. I took out her fourth paragraph because of her extreme plot summary, which was the weakest part of her essay and to save on length for this post:
Passion is the expression of a feeling to the edge. Othello is a play full of passion written by William Shakespeare approximately in 1603. The play talks about the love between Othello, a Moorish general, and Desdemona, a woman from a noble family. Shakespeare uses his characters to represent different feelings by making them do specific actions. Although the play is called Othello, the most important character is Desdemona. Shakespeare presents Desdemona as a symbol of the purity in love but also a symbol of extreme passion. He also uses her to show how when people are led by their passions everything goes wrong.
When Desdemona's father talks to her and had just found out about her secret marriage with Othello she explains that she should and will stay with Othello because of her duty as his wife. In this act we will see two different issues - the rebellion of Desdemona toward her father and her father's view of Desdemona as a possession. During the time when Othello was written there was this Elizabethan society and Shakespeare created this patriarchal Venetian society for the good of his plays. Some people will disagree with Brabantio's view of his daughter's welfare but we will consider it as the "right" way that things should be done. During the play we can see how naive Desdemona is. An example of this is when she ask Emilia, Iago's wife, whether there are women in the world that cheat on their husbands, her innocence makes her look as a pure young lady that has completely fall in love. When she tells her father that she will stay with her husband it is obvious how this emotion controls Desdemona. It makes her decide over this man that has given her education and had taking care of her during all her life and choose this other man that is now her husband. She says: "My noble father, I do perceive here a divided duty: To you I am bound for life and education; my life and education both do learn me...here's my husband, And so much duty as my mother show'd to you, preferring you before her father, so much I challenge that I may profess due to the Moor my lord." Desdemona's father on the other side accuses Othello of bewitching his daughter and denies their love. During the scene Brabantio seems to give up after talking with his daughter and realizing her true feelings. Brabantio finally let's her leave with Othello warning Othello of his now rebel wife and what she is able to do.
Due to the fact that there is a war between Venice and the Turks Othello has to leave with his army to Cyprus, a port that is a military strategic for the war. Desdemona leaves following her beloved since as she explains she cannot be without him: "That I did love the Moor to live with him, my downright violence and storm of fortunes may trumpet to the world: my heart's subdued... By his dear absence. Let me go with him," (Act 1, Scene 3). There was no wisdom in Desdemona's words since she is just thinking how she will feel if Othello is away and not in the risk that being in Cyprus might bring. We can see how Shakespeare shows Desdemona as a symbol of pure love defining pure love as of two people that cannot live without each other. Also he uses her to define extreme passion since she leaves the safety of her house to risk herself in a place under wartime.
(Fourth paragraph excluded)
In conclusion, Shakespeare uses Desdemona as a symbol to show us how our passions can lead us to paths where we can hurt or worse. As humans we are usually let our desires control us and take decisions that in the future can be harmful for us. Shakespeare presents Desdemona as a symbol of purity of love because of her innocence and loyalty towards her husband. But he also uses her as a symbol of extreme passion and to show us how when our passions control us everything goes wrong. Her rebellion towards her father is because of her unmeasured love for Othello and drove her to her own death.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The most interesting part of this essay is that Gabriela was one of the few students who focused on a character as a symbol of passion. She identified with Desdemona as a woman who directed some of the problems in the play, rather than Iago and Othello.
ReplyDeleteHer weakest part of her essay was her fourth paragraph, which I will post part of below, but it did start well with explaining how Desdemona began the drama between Othello and Iago. She explains how if Desdemona had not been driven by her passions, she may not have died due to Iago's terrible plan. Yet, the issue with her fourth paragraph was her plot summary and extreme use of quotes. This is a common issue with ELLs (and probably many high school writers in general). She could not summarize the overall problem and instead stated the whole situation, quotes and all!
Part of excluded paragraph:
ReplyDeleteAs explained before, Desdemona leaves everything that she knows to follow her husband to Cyprus during wartime. Led by this strong feeling of love she had towards Othello she departs. The drama begins when Iago, the ancient, decides to take revenge of Othello for giving Cassio, a soldier, the position of lieutenant. With the help of Roderigo, a man that is in love with Desdemona, Iago contrives a plan to destroy Othello's life. When Desdemona got to Cyprus everything started to go wrongsince the situations opened the door to misunderstanding with her husband.
Gabriela then discusses the loss of Desdemona's handkerchief as the major issue and how if Desdemona hadn't been driven by her passions, she would be alive.
She does give one great quote at the end - "We can conclude that her passion drove her to her own murder." Fantastic!
The issue was in the middle, because Gabriela quoted the entire argument over the handkerchief, which is obviously too much! Overall, she did great work.